Emily is a young, vivacious therapist who, despite her talents, has a troubled love life and a dissatisfying professional practice. She assumes that new client Josh is just going to be another run-of-the-mill patient when he first complains of the recent return of his estranged brother, a well-known character actor on TV, whom he has not seen for fifteen years. Josh eventually claims that brother Craig is shadowing him around town, disguised as different townsfolk. At first Emily is confounded by Josh’s sincere but patently delusional beliefs. Then Craig himself contacts her to discuss Josh’s situation.